Geography and Regional Planning

Geography and Regional Planning

Pathology of the realization of qualitative indicators of institution building in West Asia

Document Type : Basic scientific-research articles

Authors
Nesa Zahedi 1
Seyed Ebrahim Sarparast Sadat 2
1 Assistant Professor of Political Science, Islamic Azad University, Central Tehran Branch, Tehran, Iran
2 Faculty Member, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran, Iran
10.22034/jgeoq.2026.532113.4292
Abstract
State institutions shape political variables and political choices, and narrowing the focus from state power to the power of state institutions is the essence of research on state subordination. Because by going into details, examples, and indicators, it presents the discussion with a more limited generality and focuses on the causal relationship between the performance of administrative, political, judicial, and security institutions and measures their relationship with political stability and economic performance. Here, focusing on the political geography of West Asian countries, we want to analyze the concept of state subordination under the new institutionalist literature in the four areas of administrative, political, security, and judicial institutions and their complex and reciprocal relationships and the impact they can have on political stability and economic performance.The present article, using the method of description, analysis and resources of the library, is the answer to this question. The findings of the research are based on this belief that the state of institutionalization in the above four areas in this region, due to the lack of quality indicators such as reliance on competence and competitiveness of salaries and autonomy in the administrative area, lack of honesty, transparency and equal access and property rights in the judicial area and lack of a centralized command structure, professionalization and lack of accountability to civilians in security areas and lack of monitoring corruption, proportionality, stabilization and the prevalence of competitive bribery, lack conditions conducive to ensuring political stability and economic growth.
Keywords
neoliberalism
institutional decline
bureaucratization
منابع
فرانتز، اریکا و  ازرو، ناتاشا(1402 )، دولت های فرومانده و زوال نهادی، ترجمه امیر میرحاج، نشر شیرازه، تهران.
References
Frantz, E., & Ezrow, N. (2023). Dowlat-haye forumandeh va zaval-e nahadi [Failed states and institutional decay] (A. Mirhaj, Trans.). Shiraze. (Original work published 2011).
Robinson, james(2023)The origins Of Power.London,Uk:Crown Bussinness.
Robinson, james (2023)The Colonial Origins Of Comparative Development:An Impirical Investigation,,American Economic Review91(2001).
Alao, Charles.(2024).The Problem Of The Failed State In Africa. In International Security Management And The United Nations.United Nations University Press,
Allen, ChriS .(2022). Understanding African Politics.Review Of African Political Economy.
Amsden, Allice .(2019).H.Asia Next Giant: South KoreaAnd Late Industrializaton,Oxford University Press.
Anderson, Lisa. (2024). Political Decay In The Arab World .Paper Delivered Eighteenth Annual Joseph, Strelitz Lecture.
Angrist, Michele Penner.(2021). The Expression Of Political Dssent In The MiddleEast:Turkish Democratization And Authoritarian Continuity( Comparative Studies In Society And History
Anwaruddin, Awang.(2019). Improving Public Service Delivery Through Bureacracy  Reform.JurnalImu Administrasi1,no.4
Besley, Timothy. (2024). Property Rights And Investment Incentives:Theory And Evidence , Journal Of Political Economy.
Collire, paul .(2024). The Microeconomics Of African Growth.Thematic Paper
Brinkerhoff, Dreick W.Clientalism .(2024). Patrimonialism And Democratic Governance. An Overwie And Framework For Assessment And Programing.
Hannan, U And Basada .(2020).Dimentions Of State Fragility;A Review Of Social Sience Literature.Working Paper
Heir,Bin .(2021). The Myth Of The  Failed State And The War On Terror, Jornal Of International and Statebuilding.
Sartori, Giovanni .(2000). Party systems: A Framework For Analysis. Cambridge, Uk: Cambridge Univercity Press.
Sarre, Rick, Dilip k (2005) Policing Corruption: International Perspective Lanham, Lexington Books.
Schedler, Andreas.(2017). Democrats With Adjectives:Linking Direct And Indirect  Measures Of Democratic Support : European Journal Of   Political Research.
Schneider, Freidrich And Dominik Ense .(2017). Shadow Economies Around  The World , size, causes And Consequences, Imf Working Paper.
Jepperson, R. (2010).“Institutions, Institutional Effects and Institutionalization in Powell”, The new Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis, Chicag.